Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage

Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage: An Honest Comparison

First Advantage is one of the largest publicly traded background screening companies in the country, reporting roughly 190 million "lives serviced" [confirm current figure]. Here's how Sapphire's smaller, flat-rate, human-reviewed model compares.

Checks from $22.50 flat. No 100-employee minimum published.

Background Check Compliance for Seasonal Employees

The Short Version

First Advantage is a large, publicly traded background screening company reportedly requiring a minimum group size around 100 eligible employees for some of its programs [confirm current requirement directly with First Advantage], built for high-volume enterprise hiring. Sapphire has no published minimum size requirement and is built to serve employers of any size with transparent, flat pricing. If you’re a large enterprise that needs a public-market provider’s scale and infrastructure, First Advantage is worth evaluating directly. If you’re a small or mid-size employer who wants direct support and a clear price, Sapphire’s model is built specifically for that.

SIDE-BY-SIDE COMPARISON

How Sapphire and First Advantage Compare

Feature Sapphire Check Competitor
Pricing Model Published flat pricing: $22.50 / $45.00 / $65.00, plus published a la carte pricing No published rate card; enterprise-quoted pricing confirm directly with First Advantage
Minimum Group Size None published - serves employers of all sizes Reported minimum of approximately 100 eligible employees for certain programs confirm current requirement
Company Structure Independently operated background screening company Publicly traded company; reported to serve roughly 190,000,000 "lives serviced" confirm current figure
Report Review Criminal record hits verified at the statewide or county level before reporting Confirm current review methodology directly with First Advantage
Best Fit Small to mid-size employers, and larger organizations wanting direct, flat-rate service Large enterprises with high-volume, ongoing screening programs

Competitor-side claims are drawn from public sources (primarily Shortlister’s comparison directory) reviewed during this project; verify current figures directly with First Advantage.

WHERE SAPPHIRE STANDS OUT

Why Some Employers Choose Sapphire

1

Transparent Pricing

No published minimum employee-count requirement

2

Human Review

Transparent, flat pricing visible on our website

3

Published Add-Ons

Criminal hits verified by our own team before reporting

4

Direct Support

Direct support without a large enterprise account structure to navigate

When First Advantage Could Be the Better Fit

Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage: Common Questions

First Advantage is a publicly traded background screening company with a long operating history – legitimacy in the sense of being a real, established company isn’t in question. Evaluate fit based on your specific needs: pricing transparency, minimum group size, and review process.

Some sources report a minimum group size around 100 eligible employees for certain First Advantage programs – confirm current eligibility requirements directly with First Advantage, as this can vary by program.

Sapphire’s pricing is published directly on our site starting at $22.50. First Advantage’s pricing is enterprise-quoted – request a quote to compare directly for your needs.

Yes – Sapphire has no published minimum size requirement and serves employers of all sizes with the same flat-rate packages.

Sapphire verifies multi-state criminal hits at the statewide or county level before reporting. Confirm First Advantage’s current review methodology directly with them.

See What a Direct, Flat-Rate Alternative Looks Like.

Get a straightforward quote – no minimum employee count required.

Flat pricing · No published minimum size · FCRA-aligned