Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage
Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage: An Honest Comparison
First Advantage is one of the largest publicly traded background screening companies in the country, reporting roughly 190 million "lives serviced" [confirm current figure]. Here's how Sapphire's smaller, flat-rate, human-reviewed model compares.
Checks from $22.50 flat. No 100-employee minimum published.
The Short Version
First Advantage is a large, publicly traded background screening company reportedly requiring a minimum group size around 100 eligible employees for some of its programs [confirm current requirement directly with First Advantage], built for high-volume enterprise hiring. Sapphire has no published minimum size requirement and is built to serve employers of any size with transparent, flat pricing. If you’re a large enterprise that needs a public-market provider’s scale and infrastructure, First Advantage is worth evaluating directly. If you’re a small or mid-size employer who wants direct support and a clear price, Sapphire’s model is built specifically for that.
How Sapphire and First Advantage Compare
| Feature | Sapphire Check | Competitor |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing Model | Published flat pricing: $22.50 / $45.00 / $65.00, plus published a la carte pricing | No published rate card; enterprise-quoted pricing confirm directly with First Advantage |
| Minimum Group Size | None published - serves employers of all sizes | Reported minimum of approximately 100 eligible employees for certain programs confirm current requirement |
| Company Structure | Independently operated background screening company | Publicly traded company; reported to serve roughly 190,000,000 "lives serviced" confirm current figure |
| Report Review | Criminal record hits verified at the statewide or county level before reporting | Confirm current review methodology directly with First Advantage |
| Best Fit | Small to mid-size employers, and larger organizations wanting direct, flat-rate service | Large enterprises with high-volume, ongoing screening programs |
Competitor-side claims are drawn from public sources (primarily Shortlister’s comparison directory) reviewed during this project; verify current figures directly with First Advantage.
Why Some Employers Choose Sapphire
Transparent Pricing
No published minimum employee-count requirement
Human Review
Transparent, flat pricing visible on our website
Published Add-Ons
Criminal hits verified by our own team before reporting
Direct Support
Direct support without a large enterprise account structure to navigate
When First Advantage Could Be the Better Fit
- If you're a large enterprise already meeting First Advantage's reported group-size thresholds and need public-company-scale infrastructure, their platform may be built for that scale
- If you need very high-volume, ongoing enterprise screening programs with dedicated account management, that's a use case First Advantage is positioned around
Sapphire Check vs. First Advantage: Common Questions
Is First Advantage legit?
First Advantage is a publicly traded background screening company with a long operating history – legitimacy in the sense of being a real, established company isn’t in question. Evaluate fit based on your specific needs: pricing transparency, minimum group size, and review process.
Do I need 100+ employees to use First Advantage?
Some sources report a minimum group size around 100 eligible employees for certain First Advantage programs – confirm current eligibility requirements directly with First Advantage, as this can vary by program.
Is Sapphire cheaper than First Advantage?
Sapphire’s pricing is published directly on our site starting at $22.50. First Advantage’s pricing is enterprise-quoted – request a quote to compare directly for your needs.
Can a small business use Sapphire the same way a large enterprise would use First Advantage?
Yes – Sapphire has no published minimum size requirement and serves employers of all sizes with the same flat-rate packages.
How do the review processes compare?
Sapphire verifies multi-state criminal hits at the statewide or county level before reporting. Confirm First Advantage’s current review methodology directly with them.
See What a Direct, Flat-Rate Alternative Looks Like.
Get a straightforward quote – no minimum employee count required.
Flat pricing · No published minimum size · FCRA-aligned